Why does popular culture depict creativity as ‘chaotic’?

Sheila Chandra - Thursday, October 19, 2017

We’ve all seem the films and read the novels where the artist genius’ life is chaos. Perhaps they’re tortured by their vision of the world, perhaps they’re emotionally chaotic – but in any depiction where creativity itself is almost a main character, you’re almost sure to find visual and domestic chaos. Why is that?


Creativity as ‘chaotic’ is visual shorthand

I mean think about it. If you’re a director, or a photographer, you’ve got a real problem when depicting creativity. It happens in the artist’s head. So how on earth do you show it? How do you show that it’s part of their essence, not just an ‘event’ in their life? (Actually it is just an ‘event’ in their lives but let’s ignore that for a moment…) After all, who among us really understands what is happening when out of a void, comes the idea we’ve been searching for?

Creativity as ‘chaotic’ is convenient

There is no real way of depicting it – particularly to a viewing public who are, unconsciously I think, actually asking about how some people get to be so brilliantly creative while others are not. Ironically, novelists (and therefore screenplay writers and directors) have the answer, but all these categories of people don’t think to apply it to depictions of artistry. Why? Because the answer turns out to be just a little bit boring, and not the conflict-ridden ‘juice’ that their book, screenplay or film requires to make it successful.

Why are some people ‘creative’ and others not?

Well novelists tell us, that ‘character is destiny’. What a character thinks over and over, leads to what s/he does over and over, and those repeated actions, for good or bad, shape their life. Well, being ‘creative’ is just a tolerance for sitting with the ‘blank page’, and focusing the mind on the problem, until an idea comes. And if you do that over and over and over, it becomes ‘who you are’. Similarly, if you regularly potter about in your garden, in a few years, you’re going to be known as a ‘gardener’. And if you put some real effort into it, you’re likely to become a great gardener. Certainly more likely than if what you do is remain in your armchair… Similarly with being a brilliant creator. So, as the old joke says ‘The way to Carnegie Hall? Practice, practice, practice…’

So why do even creative people fall for the ‘creativity is chaotic’ myth?

It’s not comfortable sitting with that void. I hate it, to be honest. There’s no guarantee you’re going to come up with anything good. I’ve said that ‘being creative’ is a ‘tolerance’ for sitting with the void for a reason. Most creative people are a bit discomforted by it. And it’s only by building up a ‘tolerance’ for a discomforting experience that they get to earn the title ‘creator’.

Maybe it’s very infiniteness of possibility that’s the intimidating thing. After all, what could come out of our imaginations might not be convenient or good, but nightmarish. Every creator knows that. Maybe what popular culture is depicting in physical chaos around an artist (in novels and on stage and screen) is the fear we feel ourselves about the mystery of the whole process. And who can blame us?

Depicting creativity as ‘chaotic’ isn’t going to help

The problem is, that isn’t going to help young creators who are just finding their feet. It’s convenient enough for popular culture – not to say lazy – but it gives the wrong impression. Mess is not a mark of genius. Mess is not the inevitable result of having a good idea and being driven to realise it. Mess is not even that special. Every toddler creates it!

Let’s stop seeing creativity as ‘chaotic’ please?

Time to stop using this hackneyed old stereotype. Let’s acknowledge that the most successful artists with longevity are generally organized behind the scenes. They wouldn’t get paid properly if they weren’t. (And no, it’s not the resort of terminally ‘uncool’ artists. Have you thought about the kind of logistics Bowie had to have put in place before his death to get the ‘Blackstar’ album ready to roll in the same week?) Let’s divorce the visual shorthand from reality, the way we realise that a bunch of red roses in a film is shorthand for ‘romance’. Let’s give up-and-coming creators better role models to emulate.

If you’d like to know more about how to set up the career infrastructure you’ll need as a professional creator, download a free excerpt of ‘Organizing for Creative People’.

Post has no comments.
Post a Comment

Captcha Image


Recent Posts


wardrobe tips for clearing proposal writing confident in clothes multiple lifetimes artists self promotion creative commissions card successful artist goals artist mentors too many commitments artistry commitment nurturing creative work theft clear desk spree creative career coaching good art work effortlessly tidy proposals symptoms of creativity artistic conviction slim-line wardrobe organisation stop hoarding stuff disorganization quality green room cleaning your desk housework much quicker double standard diary streamlining routines email overload mornings clearing culture networking visualising creative identity email bankruptcy peacefulness good friend car ‘stories’ about your possessions ‘creativity’ clutter friendships diagnosis criteria for letting go of stuff cry normality artist mentoring anxiety long-term artistic development hotel room platform creative confidence introverts tension how to be naturally tidy clearing in short bursts innocence collections low maintenance creative career well curated closet hostile clutter stay on top of email working class artists efficient work patterns work trips domestic life clearing clutter professional mentors artistic chaos time clutter pop music creative person 2018 goals slow and steady funding tidiness in living spaces static spaces tidy people nipping things in the bud myth clear outs options friends feel like creatiing email emotional support social media work efficiently nurture creativity inconvenience tidy display items social media networking well organized saving time creative wellbeing touring chaotic hoarding creative organising imagination great artists tortoise and hare writing funding campaigns emotional resilience too busy copyright creative culture artist goals why organise cupboard of shame buying youth emotionally secure artist smart artists living clutter free concentrated creative time arrogance business boredom clarity of thought precious memories tidier temperament storage dynamic spaces clutter addict creative spark partners guilty purchases good creative habits exhaustion buying hope lifetimes work/home life balance making decisions business interface to creative businesses resentment VIPs control brilliant creator grief creativity diary great art business-speak nascent artists absences new year jealousy loss stop cluttering inspiration home care brands living mess free career strategy artist tidy desk buying happiness the void organise clean desk fine art sacrifice just in case celebrity endorsed products networking effectively minimalists home organising buying wealth branding stay tidy automatically warm down buy fewer clothes loving your audience how to work efficiently parent under-confidence appointments work life being organized creativity how to save time critical acclaim workspaces professional encouragement business-like organizing for creative people letting go vulnerability lazy creative ambitions creative magic bulk buy morning routines low maintenance strategies elevator pitch magic wind down home life hobbies focus much better friend artist workspaces compulsion cleaning work priorities : clothes mature artists productivity hijacking creativity sheila chandra coaching clearing as you go peer-to-peer networks pop culture being tripped up motivation emotional balance trope working class culture creative people stardust missed opportunities crowdfunding Sheila Chandra author feeling creative staying in control to do list overwork fall of innocence popular culture binge artist materials getting ready for work professional creative career buying stardust childhood network subconscious mind mess vocation procrastination